Home >> Details

Drewry: Demise of Small Carriers Cuts Competition

Your one call,our mission arrives,professional freight service,safe,fast,professional,innovative service,let you worry freely

Time:2013/5/16Copyright:Highsun



The increasing dominance of super-post-Panamax ships in the major east-west trades is forcing smaller, niche carriers out of business on those lanes and raising the barrier to further entries.

This means shippers will have less choice on the major trade lanes and will see less price competition, according to Drewry Maritime Research.

“The list of casualties is now so long that shippers have good reason to question if new blood will ever again be tempted to break the stranglehold of the establishment, and if not, what the consequences will be,” Drewry said in its latest Container Insight Weekly.

Smaller carriers, which operate smaller vessels, cannot compete against the better slot economics offered by the larger ships being deployed by the Top 20 carriers.

Hainan Pan Ocean Shipping, which deployed vessels with an average capacity of 2,700 20-foot-equivalnet units in its CAE Asia-Europe service, ended that service in November.

Grand China Shipping pulled out of the trans-Pacific trade at the end of 2011 only six months after entering it with 2,700-TEU ships. In April 2011, The Containership Company, which was operating its Great Dragon service in the trans-Pacific with 2,580-TEU ships, was forced to withdraw the service.

Also in 2011, PIL and Wan Hai had to withdraw their FES service between Asia and northern Europe because their 4,250-TEU vessels could not compete with the larger, more fuel-efficient ships being deployed by the major carriers.

Since then, MISC completely withdrew from the container market in the middle of last year and focused on the bulk shipping sector.

Drewry said no carrier outside the Top 20 lines operates ships on the Asia-North Europe route any more. And in the trans-Pacific, Wan Hai and Matson are the only non-top 20 carriers still operating vessels on this route. The trans-Atlantic trade still has four medium-sized carriers (Atlanticargo, Eimskip, ICL and Marfret) that operate ships.

“The implication is that there is no room left for small players in the east-west trade lanes, no matter what niche market experience is brought to the table,” Drewry said. “The big players’ economies of scale are now simply too big to overcome.”